|
| |
DOUBLE
WAVELENGTH (980 NM AND 808 NM) DIODE LASER
IN THE ENDOSCOPIC TREATMENT OF ANGIO-DYSPLASIAS
OF THE DIGESTIVE TRACT
EVIMEDICA Bergamo (Italy)
Endoscopy Centre General hospital of Bologna (Italy)

SUMMARY
The present
report evaluates the utilisation in digestive endoscopy of double wavelength (980 nm and
808 nm) DIODE laser.
The two different wavelengths are emitted in rapid succession by the same device.
980 nm laser is the one most frequently used in hemostasis and in the recanalization of
stenoses.
808 nm diode laser has a penetration of 2 mm (compared to 4 mm for 980 nm diode laser),
and results in less dispersion of heat, as well as a more even diffusion in adjacent
tissues. In conditions in which the gut wall is thin, it makes it possible to operate with
a higher degree of safety and a reduced risk of perforation.
This study presents some preliminary data comparing the results of successive utilisation,
on the one hand with 980 nm diode laser (28 referrals), and, on the other hand, with
double wavelength laser (16 referrals), to treat angio-dysplasias.
INTRODUCTION
The treatment of angio-dysplasias in the digestive tract as a whole, and in particular in
the cecum constitutes one of the non-palliative therapeutic applications of DIODE laser in
digestive endoscopy.
However, the DIODE laser generally utilised in digestive endoscopy (with emission of a 980
nm laser beam) gives rise to a problem in the treatment of angio-dysplasias: in the
absence of conditions of reflection, at a distance of 1 cm from the tissue, its tissue
penetration is 4 mm per cm2, per second. Consequently, in the case of a lesion in a
particularly thin bowel wall, the thermal effect may reach the deep layers of the bowel
and expose it to a risk of perforation. This risk is high in the case of treatment of
angio-dysplasias of the cecum.
DIODE laser can oscillate at two different wavelengths, 980 nm and 808 nm. It is normally
used at 980 nm because it has an energy effectiveness approximately four times greater
than that which can be obtained at 808 nm. This is why 980 nm DIODE has generally been
commercialised and used until now. However, a 808 nm wavelength, although four times less
powerful than 980 nm, offers certain advantages:
a) a depth of
tissue penetration (per cm2, per second, and at a distance of 1 cm) of 0.5 mm;
b) lower heat dispersion by the blood and a more even diffusion of laser light in the
tissues.
These
characteristics of 808 nm DIODE laser mean that it is particularly appropriate in the
treatment of angio-dysplasias.
MATERIALS AND
METHODS
Instruments
In order to obtain equipment with multiple functions, in recent years combinations have
been made of CO2 and DIODE laser. The result however has been a bulky piece of equipment
which could not be used endoscopically, since CO2 laser could not be transmitted by
optical fibres.
Two laser manufacturers have recently produced a DIODE laser which makes various functions
possible by means of the emission of two wavelengths (980 nm and 808 nm) transmitted by
the same optical fiber. In the present trial a DIODE laser was used which makes it
possible to transmit consecutively through the same optical fiber, from the same piece of
equipment, a 980 nm laser beam, and within a few milliseconds, a 808 nm laser beam.
Therefore the endoscopist has two wavelengths available, in the same optical fiber, with
an external diameter of 1 mm, both in the same piece of laser equipment, the classic 980
nm, and the 808 nm, which makes it possible to operate where 980 nm is reflected or only
slightly absorbed, namely in whitish and high water-content tissues, and in cases in which
980 nm would present a risk of perforation. As well as these characteristics, DIODE laser
presents certain significant advantages: air cooling, 220 v power supply, light weight and
portability.
The endoscopes used were Fuji operating video-endoscopes, which it was not necessary to
modify since they were already equipped with shields against DIODE laser radiation, with a
3.8 nm channel and a system of supplementary lavage.
The laser room is equipped with safety devices against laser radiation, combustion fumes
and electrical risks, in compliance with official CEI standards.
Material
Between January 1993 and March 1998, 486 patients were treated endoscopically with DIODE
laser for curative or palliative purpose. In this survey of cases, the angiodysplastic
lesions treated with two different means are divided into two distinct therapeutic
periods, A and B (Table 1):
| |
DIODE
980 nm
Period A
(1.1993-1.1997) |
DIODE 808 nm
Period B
(1.1997-3.1998) |
Number of cases proposed
for treatment
Size of the lesions (mm)
Number of cas treated
Mean number of sessions
Total energy emitted (J)
Complete eradication
Complications |
28
13 (5-20)
20 (71%)
1,5 (1-3)
1 900 (800- 3 200)
13 (65%)
none |
16
15 (6-30)
16 (100%)
1,5 (1-3)
330 (120-750)
14 (87,5%)
none |
In period A, 28
cases were referred to us with a view to endoscopic treatment with 980 nm DIODE laser. The
mean size, measured as the axis, or the sum of the longest axes of the largest lesion, was
13 mm (range 5-20). Of the 28 cases, 20 were treated (71%), while the others were excluded
because of the notable size of the lesions and the potential risk of hemorrhage and/or
perforation. The mean number of sessions required for complete eradication of the lesions
was 1.5 (range 1-3). Total energy emitted was 1 900 Joules (range 800-3 200), in brief
impulses, and with an increased power of 25 W, in order to avoid producing thermal effects
on the lower layers of the wall and to reduce the risk of perforation. Complete
eradication due to the first session of laser treatment was achieved in 13 cases
(65%). No complications were observed.
In period B, 16
cases were referred to us with a view to endoscopic treatment with DIODE laser, though
only the 808 wavelength was used. The mean size of the lesions was 15 mm (range 6-30).
All the cases referred were treated, with a mean number of 1.5 sessions (range 1-3). Total
energy emitted for the complete cycle of treatment was 330 J (range 120-750 J.). Complete
eradication was achieved in 14 cases (87,5%). No complications were observed.
DISCUSSION
The number of cases treated is clearly not sufficiently high to draw statistically valid
conclusions. Moreover, the difference in the number of cases, and in the size of the
lesions, in periods A and B, makes it difficult to make a direct comparison between them.
However, it must be remembered that these are comparatively rare pathologies, for which
the choice of indications and methods is a function of the risks incurred. This
preliminary study is one of the first applications of 808 nm DIODE laser in digestive
endoscopy. Nevertheless, these preliminary results make it possible to compare certain
data from periods A and B: the number of cases treated, the total energy emitted, the
number of complete eradications in the first cycle of treatment.
In period B, the number of cases treated was higher, and none were excluded, since there
were no counter-indications in the case of larger angio-dysplasias and those located in
positions with a high risk of perforation or hemorrhage.
Moreover, in period B the percentage of complete eradications was higher than in period A,
since it was possible to treat larger lesions more safely and effectively with 808 nm
DIODE laser. Finally, these more complete eradications were achieved with a total quantity
of energy emitted which was lower than that of period A.
No significant complications were observed during either of the two periods, but in the
period B it was possible to accept cases presenting higher risks than in period A.
CONCLUSIONS
In conclusion, 980 nm DIODE laser poses certain problems for the endoscopist in the
treatment of angio-dysplasias, because of the deep penetration of the thermal effect.
However, 808 nm appears to palliate these problems because of its more superficial
penetration. The trials carried out in the course of the past year with double wavelength
(980 nm - 808 nm) DIODE, with particular reference to the laser treatment of high risk
lesions (angio-dysplasias), indicate the utility of further studies using this
application.
The preliminary data in the present study could serve as the basis of a randomised study,
in a number of centers, of this rather infrequent pathology which, because of the location
and the dimension of the lesions, exposes the patient to a certain risk of complications
after treatment with 980 nm DIODE laser.
|